And although I covered Rollins during his best seasons (2006-09), they also represented a too-brief offensive peak. His 47.6 wins above replacement rank 26th all-time among shortstops the average WAR among Hall of Fame shortstops is 67.7. Among Hall of Fame shortstops, Smith had an OPS+ of only 87. His OPS+, for instance, is 95 - or 5% below league average - compared to Molitor (122), Henderson (127), and Morgan (132). Hall of Famer? Exploring Bryce Harper's case for Cooperstownīut the advanced metrics are unkind to Rollins. Three are Hall of Famers (Rickey Henderson, Joe Morgan, Paul Molitor) the other is Barry Bonds. Only Vizquel isn’t in the Hall of Fame.Īnd here’s the most compelling stat: Rollins is among five players with at least 230 career homers and 470 stolen bases. He played 19,513⅔ innings at shortstop, seventh all-time behind Derek Jeter, Omar Vizquel, Luis Aparicio, Ozzie Smith, Cal Ripken Jr., and Luke Appling. He was a three-time All-Star, a four-time Gold Glove winner, and the 2007 NL MVP after claiming the Phillies were “the team to beat” in the NL East and backing it up with 212 hits, 38 doubles, 20 triples, 30 home runs, 94 RBIs, and an. He’s 115th all-time in hits (2,455) and tied for 85th in runs (1,421). Rollins’ case rests with traditional metrics and achievements. And it feels to this voter, at least for now, like that’s the club to which Rollins belongs. Or Don Mattingly and Bernie Williams with the Yankees. Not every franchise icon is a Hall of Famer, though. 11 should be retired in Ashburn Alley, too. He’s a mortal lock for the team’s Wall of Fame.
#Hall of fme serial
He was a serial winner who helped change the culture of an organization and turn shiny, new Citizens Bank Park into the coolest spot in a football-crazed city. Phillies history can’t be authored without Rollins, and not just because he had more hits (2,306) than anyone who’s worn the uniform. His Hall of Fame candidacy isn’t as straightforward.
#Hall of fme series
It also began a stretch of 10 winning seasons in 11 years, including five consecutive National League East titles, back-to-back World Series runs, and the 2008 championship.īut then nobody denies J-Roll’s imprint on the franchise. Indeed, Rollins’ arrival as the everyday shortstop coincided with the Phillies’ year-over-year 21-game improvement from 2000. » READ MORE: Rollins, Bonds, Clemens make my first Hall of Fame ballot. We were so flat, and he came up and brought this jolt of energy.” “It was this youthful exuberance of just loving the game and just wanting to talk to someone about it. “I joked with Jimmy later that we should’ve had a promotional item called the ‘Jimmy Rollins Talking Bat.’ You get a hit and it would just go, ‘Oooh, did you see that? Oh my goodness! Wow, that was cool. I was looking for that,’” Glanville recalled a couple of years ago. “Every time he put the bat on the ball, he was like, ‘Dude, did you see that backspin? Oooh, yeah. And he never doubted he belonged among the lineup’s frontmen. As a rookie in 2001, Jimmy Rollins batted at or near the top of the Phillies’ order, which won him a place in an A-list batting practice group with Scott Rolen, Bobby Abreu, and Doug Glanville.